Contributions by ‘Neil S. Siegel’

In Trump v. Anderson, 144 S. Ct. 662 (2024), the Supreme Court of the United States held that the Colorado Supreme Court erred in excluding former President Donald J. Trump from the Republican Party’s primary ballot in the state. The Court reasoned that the Constitution makes Congress, not the states, solely responsible for enforcing Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment. Scholars of Section 3 have persuasively argued that Section 3 is self-executing, so the Court’s rationale lacks a sound basis in the original or contemporary meaning of the text of the Civil War Amendments, the original intent of their drafters, or the Court’s own precedent interpreting them. This Article nonetheless argues that the Court’s judgment is justifiable on structural grounds identified in the author’s recent book, The Collective-Action Constitution (2024).